“I can understand if you’re asking these questions as a devil’s advocate. But if you are having these questions, I have to question your conservatism.” – CL Bryant to me
The main reason I hadn’t waded into any political discussions on my blog is because this election cycle, I’m tired. The horserace aspect of it all doesn’t interest me. The “fate of the country as we know it” pseudo-import of it doesn’t interest me. The dialogue itself doesn’t interest me. Facebook, for example, encapsulates all of the problems, as “friendships” are reduced to labels and we conflate political discourse and personal attack. Every four years, we stop being people become labels to be vilified or demonized. Suddenly I’m not “Maurice,” I’m a political party or believe.
But writing the review of Runaway Slave has me thinking about a few issues, including the idea of being a Black Republican. [Black folks at the Democratic Convention-->]
My political journey is almost the mirror opposite of C.L. Bryant in the movie. I grew up in a (white) conservative church and had it drilled into my head that any right thinking Christian had no choice but to vote Republican (read: pro-life = WWJD). As such, my personal leanings tend to skew to the right. However, my love for social justice and environmental concerns doesn’t allow me to exist there comfortably. I believe in personal responsibility and the community taking care of its poor. I’m a capitalist who believes that with great wealth comes great responsibility, and spending has to be tempered with compassion. I think that Democrats take the black vote for granted and the Republicans have written off the black vote. And I want my taxes cut.
We give too much credence to the idea of being able to legislate our problems away; trusting too much in laws and too little in the corrupt nature of man. Republicans are going to (continue to) look racist if they simply scrap programs for the poor without having a different plan to replace it with. Democrats are going to (continue to) enable this co-dependent relationship that keeps a disproportionate amount of us suckling at the government’s teat.
Stepping on the necks of the poor all the while telling them to pull themselves up by their own bootstraps is BS and elitist: pulling ourselves up by our own bootstraps is great, if you have boots. It’s like trying to come into a game of Monopoly after everyone else has been around the board a bunch of times. Nor can you just throw money at folks as the cure for poverty. We need better, more comprehensive strategies for dealing with poverty. [<-- Black folk at the Republican Convention]
I live in a state of tension: I don’t trust government, want it shrunk, but want it to do what it’s supposed to do. The government does have a role to play in things, after all: in spending on education, in supporting the working poor in their efforts to pull themselves up. Yet I also value personal responsibility. Our responsibility is to value education. We have a history as scientists, artists, business people, and explorers. More than being athletes, entertainers or drug dealers, education is the best sure route out of poverty.
President Obama took 95% of the Black vote in 2008. The Joint Center for Economic and Political Studies put the number of black delegates at the Republican convention at 46—about 2% of the delegate population (in 2008, only 36 of the 2,380 delegates seated on the convention floor were black, the lowest numbers since they have been tracked). And I can’t help but wonder just how many black people are in Mitt Romney’s inner circle.
Republicans can’t get out of their own way when it comes to being the messengers. Employing their Southern Strategy, gaining political support in the Southern section of the country by appealing to white fears (racism), seems inbred into their very DNA at this point. They like to play coy, being too smart by half using racially loaded language and imagery (from tar baby to throwing spears), yet telling themselves they’re not being racist. The way the party is presented, there’s neither an attempt to reach out to black votes nor an embrace of black voters. And, real world interactions have taught me that having a place where you feel you belong often trumps any differences in ideology. The Republican party needs to do more than stick a Negroes Welcome sign on their doors or else they’re going to be getting a lot more letters from former black conservatives.
Now back to my regular blogging …





The first time I saw that ‘Don’t Re-Nig’ bumper sticker, I was so shocked and horrified I almost rear-ended that pickup truck. Thankfully, I stopped short of that political discourse.
That sticker still horrifies me.
Americans and their slogans! :/
(Thank you for emailing me btw Maurice: with notification that you were tackling these subjects. I have the feeling it was something you needed to get out of the way!)
I think C L Bryant is right, actually. I think you aren’t a very strong (modern) conservative. Your social liberalism – and basic honesty – gets in the way of it every time! The true conservative in the Republican mode needs a combination of the characteristics of Ayn Rand and Ebenezer Scrooge!
I’d make like your brother and write an ex-conservative letter. The only thing is.. in all honesty and political analysis, I don’t think you are likely to be that much better served by the modern Democratic party either: *because their leadership isn’t very socially liberal or progressive either*; because if they were, Obama wouldn’t be such a wuss, he would stand up stoutly to all attacks from the right wing, Gitmo would be closed and you would all have Canadian-style single-payer healthcare! NOW: no ifs, no buts,
no excuses!
Because that’s what Obama was elected to do, by most of the people who voted for him. Now that he’s weaselled and wussed out, where are the people to turn?! Towards a corporate raider and job-destroying crook? I don’t think so!
Americans really have greater problems right now than a few vaguely insulting code words! Like – how about the necessity for the formation of a new mass political party, for the masses?
If it’s religion most visitors to these pages are worried about, and you’d never vote for a godless communist atheist – why not try voting for Michael Moore, if you ever get the chance? Because *he’s* religious – a Roman Catholic Christian – and always has been: never has experimented with anything else, to my knowledge. But you just try to see if the public knows that – not with the media you have, which obscures rather than informs! He had to yell rather loudly about it at the time of his last documentary, if memory serves me, before any talking head would acknowledge it! (Maybe there’s
a problem on the side of the left, too, come to think of it, with that aspect of the infowar – because a lot of the left is a bit ashamed for different reasons to acknowledge religious belief, aren’t they? Also many left-wing media people have historically been secular Jews – and they’ve never wanted to advertise Catholicism!
)
But religions are like opinions and like.. something else! Everyone has one: some sort of belief system! Or preferred information processing context, which is usually a mythology.
We all have one..
Talking about the code word wars: I do think Michelle Bachman is an awful tit. And that person on the other site is right: you can’t wave around a tar baby doll: it would fall on Michelle’s head and then where would she be? Perhaps it already has!
I love the folktale though. Of the entrapping icon made of tar. Really in its best form it’s a quintessential Brer Rabbit story (he’s a super Trickster: all rabbit heroes are!) BUT the payoff only comes in the coda of the tale:
the “brier patch” sequence, in which Brer Rabbit uses his wits and acting ability to escape Brer Fox’s tarry trap! (My Patron, Loki, is very admiring of this wile! Persuading the fox to throw the rabbit just where the rabbit needs to be: Loki thinks he would have had a hard job pulling that one off himself! Truly, Brer, says the Mischief God, like your more modern descendant Bugs, you are one heck of a Wascally Wabbit! (Cavalier-style bow here.))
THAT’s what stories are for: not for the likes of Bachmann to ruin!
As for the spear-chucking.. you know I’ve never seen the sense in this one as an insult? You barely see an old play or an opera without WHITE people holding spears in it..
Pagans are proud spear-chuckers! Especially re-enactor types. The only difference is that all our spears have runes on them: like Odin’s.
Or is “spear-chucker” only an insult to/by people who aren’t Earth-centred, and therefore believe themselves too “civilized” and “advanced” to pick up a spear?
Can’t be much of an insult then, among D&D aficionados, or RPG players, or indeed most computer gamers.. Just trying to work all the implications out!
I’m a liberal by choice and a Democrat because I have none. I refuse (in fact, I can’t in good concience) be a member of a political party that actively denigrates me, my family and my friends. That makes me feel incredibly unwelcome and then has the nerve to wonder why I think they are racist and won’t give them my vote.
I would vote Republican, if I could do so without vomiting. I don’t hate Republican ideals and I’m financially conservative but the incarnation of the party right now just turns my stomach. Religious and social extremism just run rampant. For my own peace of mind I have to choose the lesser of two evils. (Does the Democratic party exploit POC? Yes. But at least I get flowwers and a kiss before they ask me to bend over.)
Yeah: I’m pretty sure I can see what Lkeke means too: though what a distressing metaphor!
This idea of lesser-evilism: it’s one we all need to get away from eventually though..
Hmm: Interesting that the Republicans may be putting off quite a few people who might otherwise vote for them!
How many middleclass black people – or POC – are there, really, though?? Maybe that’s why the Rethugs don’t care.
And in a country whose wealth is decreasing and its middle class rapidly shrinking – *how many of them, seriously, should be thinking of voting Republican at all??* OR Democrat?
(Acttually, I’d be interested to see, for how long the US could continue, *if for at least one election, or two, only between, say 20 – 30% of the eligible population voted*?!? Could the two Grand Out-Of-Touch Parties really sustain the charade of democracy like that?! Best would be, I think, if well over 50% of adults – between 60 – 70%, REGISTERED to vote, but either abstained, or voted for alternative parties!
(You’ll always be “Maurice”, just Maurice, to me, Mo!
(Or fill in other nickname, peeps, but be careful – he’s choosy!
VERY choosy..)
Yeah: it’s not exactly a very exciting election or choice of candidates, is it?! A terrible opportunist on the one hand – and another on the other, the main one being that the white guy is a member of a minority religion with a history of discriminating against black folks – and him and some of his crazy friends even more so, want total control over women’s bodies, to the extent of getting to define rape, and outlawing abortion in rape and presumably all other instances.. Hmm if I were a US woman or minority person, maybe I probably would be voting Obama.. See in YOUR country – well maybe in UK too to a lesser extent – it’s a case of keeping NUTS and bigots out of office.. But the mainstream political parties CAN’T keep relying on that factor for too long..
People are already having other ideas…!
I debated with myself whether to include this, but I found it..
..on a pagan site!
http://www.spiritualforums.com/vb/showthread.php?t=27753&page=3
Hope that comes out at the right page! (It’s a post near the bottom.)
The PERFECT write-in candidate, don’t you think, Maurice! (Well maybe for YOU, he might say!
)
Any more ideas for write-in candidates, people?
I looked on Facebook but could only find the write-in site of two dogs, one of which is named for the personage mentioned at the site above!
Any advance on suggestions???
C’mon this is America! You should be able to do better than this!!
Yes – Americans are currently a very strange people – ! – who appear to set great store by “code words”, which are supposed to and do irk minorities, and cause the white right pundits who utter them to smirk with superiority.. Foreigners who look on as I do must find it all very weird and pointless – even if we *do* have a fair idea of what you all are talking about!
This “tar baby” thing.. It’s strange but looking at my emails *I mentioned the phrase to Maurice before the Bachmann thing came out*, quite innocently, as one of my favourite folktales! (Didn’t Disney make this one too?!) I saw the “tar baby” as a universal metaphor for, not race, but all traps! I may well have called the Republican Party a tar-baby-akin trap – plus the whole rotten two-party system which has been set up by, and runs now even more solely for the benefit of the elite – and NOT the working – or the middle – class! I probably said I’m surprised you US are taken in by the whole pack of SHILLS! But maybe ure NOT – or more wd vote!
[...] Runaway Republicans – I guess this was the capper of my unintended look at the Republican Party. This began with my review of the documentary on black conservatives, Runaway Slave, ramped up with my interview with the documentary’s creator, C.L. Bryant. [...]